This started out as an open letter to Senator Orrin Hatch. Then the choirs began chiming in this morning.
To declare that a "Holy War" will be waged over the proposed Quality, Affordable Health Care for All Americans, HR 3590 - the Senate Democratic proposal for Health Care Reform - is the most irresponsible, disrespectful, disastrous and despicable thing I think I've ever heard - especially coming from a heretofore respected member of the United States Senate.
I've always respected, and at times wandered or even ran into the melee, over religious "rights". I've worked with Evangelicals and Mormons over the years, with a great degree of success in the end.
Years ago, when embarking on what turned out to be a very successful community project, we were faced with working with the local stake of the Mormon Church. Mr. Blondetwit wasn't at all comfortable with this to begin with, and was beginning to panic.
I commented to him, "What the hell's your problem? You sound like a straight man being pushed into a gay bar!"
Mr. Blondetwit responded, "What if they try and convert us?"
Gee dear, "Just how convertible are you?" The exchange changed his perspective permanently.
People that know who and what they are and believe can't be converted. It's pretty simple. Or so I thought.
I never worried much about it. I have a significant biblical education. I've also studied - at great length - the Koran, The Book of Mormon and the Pearl of Great Price, the Kaballah, and a few other things. I prefer Winnie the Pooh. I'm only partially kidding.
For every person who's ever tried to convert me, and there's been many, it took no time to determine that their understanding of what they were proseletyzing was inferior to my own understanding. When you don't understand it, you look the fool - not just zealous.
I used to be "there" once. That's how I got started learning everything else. A teenage journey gone awry you might call it. I wanted to be able to argue my "beliefs" to anyone who came my way and would challenge me. And I couldn't! I mean, I couldn't even fake it! No matter how I tried to support it, I could not.
All of this is so similar to people who send out the endless email hoaxes...they think they know, it seems to make sense, and someone they got it from said they "checked Snopes, and it's TRUE". Well, no, it's not.
There's a problem that arises when you can't any longer support your argument. You must build a fortress to protect it. A way to keep out dissent. A community to support your common beliefs, no matter how flawed. And the longer it goes on, the deeper the protection must get. The harsher the rhetoric to drown out the dissent. Any dissenters from within are handled within, until they're expelled, and then they're discredited to the outside. For everyone thrown out, more are taken in. It's a net gain.
Why anyone would want to possess a and espouse a philosophy so flawed, I don't quite understand. But then again, Mr. Blondetwit has a worn out old Seattle Mariners t-shirt he won't let go of either. I've never thought it was harmful to me, so I never made a move to eliminate it. Same with people and their religions. Not any more.
Some call me an atheist. I don't. I don't have any need to be called anything at all. I have a quiet understanding of my place in the Universe. You call that "faith". Only I don't have white knuckles to go along with
my faith. I've never had the need to defend my lack of "faith". I still don't now, because the laws of this land - currently - protect me from having to defend it.
But you people have crossed the outrage line.
As a person OF religion, you have NEVER been persecuted in this country - it's a primary factor this country is all about. Freedom OF RELIGION guarantees your freedom from persecution.
So, what have you done with that freedom? You've sought to eliminate my freedoms and the freedoms of others in the name of your religions. In regards to health care, you've managed to make health care into a system that is no longer accessible by me. It didn't use to be that way. I used to go to the doctor and pay the bill on my way out the door. In thousands of communities around this country, many don't realize that there are no physicians that are not captive in HMO or like entities. If you don't belong, you can't access. And they do not accept people with pre-existing conditions. For all the people who are struggling with chronic diseases like Lupus, MS, etc., we didn't bring these things on ourselves.
I won't even discuss all the other things you fight in the name of your religions. Perhaps you should sit back, not talk and listen to your friends, but perhaps to your God. You've drowned out the very guidance of your God with the venomous vitriol played on your radios and televisions.
Up to this point, I've been happy to defend your religious views, but now you're dragging me into your religious actions. And I'm not allowing you to do that any more.
From here on, I will require of you my religious friend, to know your leadership resume. The one that chronicles your leadership within your actions. If you're Christian, I want to know what you've done to speak out about those who murder. Those who choose to rape this earth God gave us. And if you're my Muslim friend, I want to know where you've spoken out in leadership against terrorists and the beliefs that lead them to find death more precious than life. You know who you are.
Senator Hatch and all other elected leaders: LEAD! Not by threatening Holy War. If you don't prevail in this health care debate, so what? You've lost other battles, many more disastrous than this could possibly be. But the rest of us are counting on you to do the right thing - and that doesn't involve Holy War. If you're threatening it, it could only be for one reason - you are on the losing end of this, your argument has run out and is in threat of collapse.
You have just tipped the final card that tells the rest of us your intentions. I won't turn my head any more and pass you people off as well-meaning but mis-guided.
You want a Holy War? You're on.
Like a child, throwing a temper tantrum on their bedroom floor, surrounded by the toys they won't pick up - be prepared to lose your toys Bubba. You wrote this script. And you're giving 5 year old's a bad name.